59 "A Navajo Tradition"
66
Something I believe we should consider.
“A Navajo Tradition”
Something I believe we should consider.
Back in the days of the so-called “wild” Indians, the Navajo had a ritual that they still use today, and I feel this idea should be considered for use today in some cases. Not necessarily the ritual, but the tradition or idea.
My brother-in-law is constantly researching his ancestry in south eastern Colorado. Also, in his history finding searches, he has done a lot of investigating of the Indian background, especially in that area, mostly the Ute and Navajo tribes of southern Colorado and New Mexico.
Anyway, he brought to my attention a certain ritual that the Navajo went through to deal with their “wrong-doers”. They still perform this ritual to a certain extent.
By Navajo tradition, life is continuity or betrayal. A Hataalii is a Navajo singer who is both, a singer and a councilor. Hozho, to the Navajo, is living in harmony. [Meaning the absence of ambiguity, uncertainty and indecision.]
The Navajo Hataalii ceremony reenacts some historic situation and is viewed both as a means of preserving history and a way to influence ideas of an audience.
The Navajo Hozho is designed to bring a “wrong-doer” back into harmony. By comparison, the Bilagaanii (white man) justice often favors punishment over treatment*. This to some is viewed as revenge. Perhaps the true concept of Hozho, to a Hataalii, allows ceremonial adjustment to achieve human adjustment. As a means of historic preservation the ceremony is more often subject to interpretation than a written history and may evolve quicker into inaccuracies. Thus, like many natural acts, can be correctly judged both good and bad when taken out of context of a specific setting.
*Punishment is a result of a cultural placing of blame, which to Hataalii is best treated by character reinforcement. By traditional Navajo culture negative thoughts or speaking can cause bad things to happen.
Anyway, the article above made me think about how we treat; or should I say punish, our criminals today. Sure there are the ones that need actual punishment, but then there are some that we punish that could be treated. I admit that the courts do look at this at times, but in my eyes, not often enough.
There are young people that are first time offenders that are incarcerated with older, hardened criminals that could be treated. By being placed in the situation they are, probably, off the top of my head, 90% of the time hardened themselves.
Although the Indians in general were considered uneducated, which they were, and sometimes animals, they were very intelligent in their own rights. And I feel they were really in touch with the inner self a lot more than the white man, at that time and now. I feel that we could learn a lot from them even today, if we would just listen.
Greg
vote upvote downshareprintflag
- Useful (4)
- Funny
- Awesome (3)
- Beautiful (2)
- Interesting (13)
CommentsLoading...
Hi W20, Thank you for the visit, comment and vote. Greg
Hi gregas,
I 100% agree with you and this article, to me, was a bounty of truth and sadness.
Truth because we do not offer "rehabilitation" and only demean people who have done wrong, not enhance any good inside them. Even for the "hardened" criminal I believe they need to be given proper guidance to a better life. For the ones that are not able to understand right from wrong, then a safe environment, hospital per say rather than a cell to protect them and others.
I feel sadness for the lack of respect for the Native Americans and they may lack "western" education but the defy human integrity bar none.
Beautiful, awesome, interesting Gregas.
Hi Jen, Thank you for the visit, comment and vote. The Native Americans are, and always have been, a very proud people. Every one I have ever met holds that pride. Greg
Wow gregas. You can write, brother. What is that old Alice's Restaurant line? More than two is a movement.
I worked with beyond "at risk" teens for ten years. I left Devereux to work with a state funded first time offender vocational program. It never got all the way off the ground before the regime changed and the funding was axed. Now I am freelance and the Florida politicians are squawking about rising crime rates and harsher laws. I have seen with my own eyes how the offender can become a leader in the right direction. It is not part of our system. Kick everyone out of Washington and let the First Nation have their seats back!
Your richly worded article made me choke back a sob. You said, ". . . the absence of ambiguity, uncertainty and indecision." That is my new goal.
Hi Chip, Thank you for the comment and the compliment. Yep, to me that's a good way to live. Andyes, a big change in DC is needed, and I hope the people of this country will see that this year. We really can't wait for another 4 years of "indecision". Greg
The teaching of many Indian tribes were "right on" and recipes for living successfully not only with one another but the earth itself. Great Hub - well written and excellent subject matter. UP! Best, Sis
Hi Angela, Thank you for the visit, comment and votes. The world could possibly be better if we had learned their ways instead of forcing them into ours. Greg
I forget which tribe and location maybe in Africa, but as I understand it..an entire village would get together and make a circle around the person who committed an act unbecoming of their values. The each person of the village would say something nice and compassionate about the person. The idea was to balance the person. Reminding them they are love and one. Great hub.
Hi Rachel, Thank you for the visit and the comment. It is really amazing what us so-called civilized people could learn from the so-called uncivilized people. Greg
I agree with you. We could learn a lot from the Indian..Thank you for a well written hub..
As the saying goes "listen to the dull and the ignorant because they too have their story." In other words, no matter how stupid or uneducated you may conceive another person to be, you can learn something from them, if you just listen to what they have to say!Suffice to say, I personally think we could learn a lot from the Indian,if we were more opened to their culture and beliefs.
Hi Always Exploring and Mackyi, Thank you both for the visits and comments. Yes, if we would just open hearts and listen we could learn a lot, no matter who is speaking or acting. Greg
Indians have always fascinated me and let's not forget they have come so far. Today there are Indians who are real great business people and have their own businesses.It is great that they have not forgotten their traditions and rituals which they can still pass on to the next generations.
"Never Judge A Man Until You've Walked Two Moons In His Moccasins" We can learn so much from the Indians. Our society has lost touch with the spirit - whether that be God or mother earth or whatever spiritual guidance you believe in - it is our inner spirit and morality. Uh oh, I'm going to start preaching, better get off that track. Your hub is really good and well written. Thanks Gregas. Voted up.
@tillstonian - finally . . . someone gets the saying right.
Hi Tillson, Thank you for the visit, comment and vote. Yes, that i a good way to say it and we do need to look at our own inner spirit. Greg
Yes Chip, That is the right way to say it. Greg
Hi Gypsy, Thank you for the visit and the comment. Yes, the indian has always fascinated me too and they have come a long way. Greg
Very interesting hub. I've always found the Navajo to be a very interesting people. Voted up and interesting!
Hi Daniella, Thank you for the follow, visit, comment and vote. Yes, they are a very interesting people. Greg
Native American wisdom has taught me much.
Hi Ahiah, Thank you for the visit and the comment. Trust me, it could teach most peple a lot. Greg
Very interesting. I was unfamiliar with this concept or approach, but it sounds like a very effective humanistic and community based way to reintegrate people into society.
Hi Phdast, Thank you for the visit and comment. The more I read about the indians, the more I understand them and their ways. Greg
Thank you for a beautifully written and inspiring article. I agree, we could benefit in so many ways from those that were here before us.
Greg, for the past couple of years I have had this feeling, (inner voice) uttering back to basics, and being a person who firmly believes in confirmation, I was a little more than scared the first time this message was "confirmed". Several times since has it been confirmed and each time solves part of the bigger picture. I know in my knower what it is that I am suppose to be doing, now for the hard part. Doing it.
Thanks again for a well written hub.
P.S. I know its late, but, this is the first hub I have read from you, and would like to say welcome to the hub. I know you will enjoy.
Hi Mom, Thank you for the visit and comment. I think going back to the basics would do the whole world some good. Greg
I thought your hub was very interesting! Vote up! I love articles that make me use my noodle!
This is true about treating criminals. So many made mistakes in their youth and even after release, having paid for their mistakes, are stigmatized for life. It seems that while Native Americans were busy surviving and being spiritual, the "white man" was busy conquering and making money. All have aggression of some form, but maybe for different purposes.
For criminals, going to jail is like going to school,
When you come out, you're better at the crimes you do ... not my lines but I do think they're true. I lived most of my teenage/adult life in between ghettos ... still do.
I certainly think the Navajo attitude to wrong-doers sounds much better, in my opinion. Thank You for sharing this. I appreciate it. : )
May Wakan Tanka guide your path.
Hi Mr. Happy, Thank you for the visit and comment. I just know that sometimes there are people that go to prison, or even jail for something minor and come out even worse than they were before, as you said, they went to school. Greg
I agree with Mr Happy in that jail is like a school for criminals. Even if you aren't one going in you will certainly come out as one!
I love your hub as I have a great affinity for the Native American Indians and their wonderful culture. I am glad our paths have crossed and I look forward to reading more of your hubs. Thank you.
Hi SW, Thank you for the visit and especially the comment. Greg
There is certaily much wrong with our 'justice' system - too many unhappy and ill people in jail. Unfortune, unlucky and victims. Often people seem to be jailed simply because somebody has to atone when something goes wrong.
Hi Barbara, Thank you for the follow, visit and comment. I can see where some are punished just to teaco others a lesson, and that is surely wrong. Greg
Interesting and useful hub and will definitely spend additional time here. Listening and examples of love and forgiveness have proven to be better teaching methods than punishment and isolation. We need to think about the response we want and then choose the path to achieve it.
I enjoy learning all I can about the Native Americans. We've called them barbarians meaning without culture, then tried to make them forget their culture, profited from their culture and now finally beginning to understand and accept their culture.
Thanks for choosing to remind us there are alternative ways to live and maintain harmony.
Hi Sweethearts, Thank you for the visit and comment. It is really too bad that we can't get the thoughts and feelings of some of our hubber friends out for more people to read and share. Greg
Hi gregas,
I enjoyed the sentiment in this article. We still use the word rehabilitation in our prison system, but our prison system does not often rehabilitate, as you point out. Hozho seems a much healthier approach. I went to Coconino County Community College in Flagstaff, Arizona, where there were a lot of Navaho and Hopi students, and I have been on the Navaho reservation many times. Thanks for the piece.
Hi Bear, Thank you, Our system seems to think it is better to punish in prison and then rehabilitate with a period of perole, where they are still punishing them with sometimes unfair restrictions. Greg
What an interesting tradition - I appreciate that you laid out the possible negative of misinterpretation of history while praising the overall idea.
You are right, we need more treatment versus pure judgment. It is a sad thing to contemplate that a young offender can be led into a harder and more criminal lifestyle when lumped with those older and harder offenders. Our system sucks somewhat and when so many prisons are overflowing, something isn't right.
I agree that we shouldn't exalt the native American culture wholesale, but respect their culture and recognize that at least some of their practices and philosophies are worth adopting - like thanking an animal killed for food and using every part for something useful. In this, the white man is a plague.
Hi Mark, Thank you for your inspiring and agreeable answer. Greg
I think the problem boils down to money. If money were not an issue, we could separate those whom we might be able to help. As it stands, prisons are bureaucratic institutions (just like schools in many ways) that treat all criminals the same because doing so is efficient and cheaper. Pretty sad state of affairs!
Hi TT, Thank you. Yes it probably does boil down to money. But it does cost an awful lot to keep them in prison, and then they go through rehabilitation afterwards anyway while on parole. Greg
Great Hub. Very interesting and thought-provoking. I was glad to knew learn new stuff about Navajo thinking and culture. I think it's great that some judges in the US choose to run some rehabilitation programs to really give young people a chance of getting straight and acquiring some responsible values rather than going straight to prison. May they have every success. (The young people and the judges!)
Hi Keri, Thank you. I believe that the young people need help instead of being put in school with hardened criminals. Greg
Great hub. Voted up!
Hi Donald, Thank you. Thank you for the vote too. Greg
"*Punishment is a result of a cultural placing of blame, which to Hataalii is best treated by character reinforcement. By traditional Navajo culture negative thoughts or speaking can cause bad things to happen."
Negative thoughts and speech can cause bad things to happen is also a scriptural principle.
"Death and life are in the power of the tongue,
And those who love it will eat its fruit."(Prov18:21)
Hi Will, Thank you. In any language, negative thoughts or speaking can cause bad things to happen, if you stop to think about. I just like the treatment better than the punishment, in most cases anyway. Very good point with the Proverbs quote. Greg
writer20 Level 8 Commenter 4 months ago
Great hub. Voted up and interesting.